37.5 C
Wednesday, November 25, 2020

Doctors are charging some patients based on ‘perceived wealth’, according to NIB

Must Read

Ian Pullen: Third person charged over NZ firefighter’s death

A third person has been charged over the death of a NZ firefighter pilot whose body was found on the side of a...

Steve Smith: Batting genius desperate to play India after a month without a game

Steve Smith has been getting late-night messages to stop shadow batting in his hotel quarantine room, and India could bear the brunt after...


WOMEN seeking breast reductions are being charged based on perceived wealth, a top health fund says, leading to bills up to 10 times the Government-recommended charge.

Men face a similar rip-off for prostate removal.

In levelling the accusations, insurer NIB has also taken a swipe at the most expensive surgeons and specialists, saying they aren’t necessarily the best.

By the end of the year, NIB — which insures more than one million people — plans to expose overrated medicos by making charges and outcomes public.


“We will start to give patients information about performance so they are not just relying on price as a signal of quality,” NIB CEO Mark Fitzgibbon told News Corp Australia.

“Consumers tend to think the most expensive doctors are the best. There is no evidence to support that.”

The outcomes data will be based on follow-up surveys with patients.

The pricing information, to be published on a NIB-run website called Whitecoat, will also reveal how often doctors lumber patients with out-of-pocket expenses.

Some charge no more than the Medicare Benefits Schedule, or MBS. When that happens, Medicare pays 75 per cent of the bill and the fund covers the rest. For a breast reduction, the MBS fee is $900; for a prostatectomy, $1935.

Insurers recognise the MBS fee can be too low, so offer a higher amount. If the medico agrees, there is no “gap” charge for the patient.


In NIB’s case, for breast reduction the no-gap fee is $1320. It is $2941 for a prostatectomy.

But policyholders have been hit with fees of more than $9500 for breast reduction and over $10,000 for a prostate procedure.

Within four months NIB will be providing patients with data on how often a surgeon sticks to the no-gap price.

That would empower those who face paying over that figure to question why.

When Mr Fitzgibbon was asked why he thought some patients were charge more, he said: “Certainly a doctor’s perception of their wealth would be a factor.”

Australian Medical Association vice president Dr Tony Bartone said while some patients might get a discount based on their perceived inability to pay, no-one paid extra.


“We don’t do an assets and liabilities (assessment) unless they put their Rolls keys on the desk,” Dr Bartone said.

The AMA publishes its own list of suggested charges for surgeries. For a breast reduction it is $4465, according to NIB. That is less than half what some women have had to pay.

Dr Bartone said when patients were charged a multiple of the AMA fee, “that is a cause for concern”.

And he said it was true “price does not equal quality”.

The Royal Australian College of Surgeons declined to comment.

NIB’s ambitious plans for Whitecoat include tailoring it for use by the 3.7 million people insured with Bupa and the one million covered by HBF.

Online Source: news.com.au

Latest News

Coronavirus NSW: Restrictions to be eased before Christmas

NSW has announced 30 people will be allowed in one home from next week - but there’s a way you can get 50...

Will Pucovski: Australian coach says batting dynamo won’t replace Matthew Wade or Travis Head

Will Pucovski can “bat anywhere” in the Australian Test team, but Justin Langer says that doesn’t mean he gets in to play India.Australian...

Surf Life Saving Australia asks beachgoers to Adopt an Hour

Australian beachgoers are being asked to pay for every hour they spend at the beach this summer as part of a bold new...

Coronavirus SA: Woodville Pizza Bar worker breaks silence

The pizza shop worker whose lie led to South Australia’s unnecessary shutdown has broken his silence about the matter for the first time.The...

Victoria budget: New trams and enviro-friendly buses funded

Victorian commuters can enjoy a new fleet of Australian-made trams and planet-friendly buses under plans unveiled in the state budget.A new tram fleet...