Community

Sydney woman prosecuted for taking abortion drug

Sydney woman prosecuted for taking abortion drug

A Sydney woman who bought pills on the internet to abort her child after her boyfriend urged her to terminate the pregnancy has been prosecuted for self-administering a drug to procure a miscarriage.

In a decision on July 5, made public on Monday, Local Court magistrate Geoffrey Hiatt said the woman, who was 28 at the time, had a “clear intent to procure a miscarriage”.

She was sentenced to a three-year good behaviour bond.

Magistrate Hiatt noted “the ongoing debate regarding pro- and anti-abortion is a polarising issue within the community” and said it was his job to apply the law rather than “express views either way”.

It is an offence under the NSW Crimes Act for a pregnant woman to unlawfully administer to herself “any drug or noxious thing” or unlawfully use “any instrument or other means” with the intention of procuring a miscarriage.

The offence is punishable by up to 10 years’ jail but the case was dealt with summarily – without a jury – in Blacktown Local Court where the maximum sentence that can be applied is two years.

The court heard the woman, who had five children between four and nine, fell pregnant in February 2015.

At about 19 weeks, her boyfriend informed her that he did not want her to have the child but she did not act upon this.

“At about 26 weeks into the pregnancy her boyfriend again urged her to terminate the pregnancy,” the magistrate said.

“She told her boyfriend that it may be too late to have an abortion. She contacted a number of clinics in NSW and interstate and was refused from all of them on the basis that her pregnancy was past 20 weeks.”

The court heard the woman eventually tracked down a man on the internet called “Patrick” who sold her the abortion drug misoprostol for $2000.

She took the pills on September 2, 2015, when the foetus was 28 weeks and was taken to Blacktown Hospital by a friend after she started to feel unwell.

“An emergency caesarean section was performed and the child was born,” magistrate Hiatt said.

The woman’s lawyer argued there was a “problem” applying the law in this case because it appeared to be directed to circumstances where the foetus did not survive.

But the magistrate said in his view “it makes no difference whether the foetus survives independently or not outside the womb”.

The court heard expert medical evidence that a miscarriage was considered a “spontaneous” rather than deliberate pregnancy loss under 20 weeks of gestation.

After 20 weeks, the death of the foetus was considered a still birth.

A foetus was considered “pre-viable” up to 20 weeks, meaning it could not survive on its own. A 28-week-old foetus was “viable”.

An abortion was described by the expert as “a deliberate or induced event generally at a time when the foetus is expected to die as a result of the event”.

The woman’s lawyer relied on this evidence to argue a miscarriage had not occurred because the foetus was not under 20 weeks.

But the prosecution said Parliament did not intend to limit the operation of the Crimes Act to cases where a woman intended to procure a miscarriage “prior to the non-viable gestation period”.

Mr Hiatt agreed with the prosecution and said the law protected a foetus “from the time of conception through all stages of pregnancy to the point of birth”.

Accepting the argument advanced for the woman “would produce the absurd notion that it is illegal to unlawfully procure a miscarriage when a foetus is pre-viable but legal to unlawfully do so when the foetus is viable”, he said.

Online Source: www.smh.com.au

Community

More in Community

Maddington man who's claimed division 1 six times reveals his winning lotto strategy

Maddington man who’s claimed division 1 six times reveals his winning lotto strategy

The Indian TelegraphNovember 20, 2017
Police seize 700kg of cocaine and arrested three men in international drug trafficking bust

Police seize 700kg of cocaine and arrested three men in international drug trafficking bust

The Indian TelegraphNovember 16, 2017
Popular swimming spot shuts down

Popular swimming spot shuts down

The Indian TelegraphNovember 13, 2017
Why the dual citizenship saga wouldn’t have played out this way under Tony Abbott

Why the dual citizenship saga wouldn’t have played out this way under Tony Abbott

The Indian TelegraphNovember 6, 2017
Teen critical after Blacktown shopping centre stabbing

Teen critical after Blacktown shopping centre stabbing

The Indian TelegraphNovember 2, 2017

Murder charge laid after Ms. Parwinder Kaur dies from burns in 2013

The Indian TelegraphNovember 1, 2017

Video of Ms. Parwinder kaur’s husband revealed

The Indian TelegraphNovember 1, 2017
parwinder

Husband of Parwinder Kaur arrested following her death in Sydney’s north-west in 2013

The Indian TelegraphNovember 1, 2017
Abbott's belief in India and political conservatism

Abbott’s belief in India and political conservatism

The Indian TelegraphOctober 31, 2017
Jie Curtis has been jailed for at least seven years for the ‘terrifying’ attacks

Jie Curtis has been jailed for at least seven years for the ‘terrifying’ attacks

The Indian TelegraphOctober 31, 2017
Brisbane man stabbed to death after investigating power cut to his Kuraby home

Brisbane man stabbed to death after investigating power cut to his Kuraby home

The Indian TelegraphOctober 30, 2017
Traffic delays on Sydney Harbour Bridge after crash

Traffic delays on Sydney Harbour Bridge after crash

The Indian TelegraphOctober 25, 2017
Chhath 2017: Delhi Government Announces Public Holiday On Chhath Puja

Chhath 2017: Delhi Government Announces Public Holiday On Chhath Puja

The Indian TelegraphOctober 25, 2017
We Finally Have A Real Pic Of India From Space On Diwali

We Finally Have A Real Pic Of India From Space On Diwali

The Indian TelegraphOctober 23, 2017
'It Was Going To Eat Her' - Australian Teen Survives Deadly Shark Attack

‘It Was Going To Eat Her’ – Australian Teen Survives Deadly Shark Attack

The Indian TelegraphOctober 23, 2017
What is Diwali? Everything you need to know about the Festival of Lights

What is Diwali? Everything you need to know about the Festival of Lights

The Indian TelegraphOctober 20, 2017
A taste of Bollywood in Hobart’s CBD as Franklin Square hosts Diwali, the Indian festival of light

A taste of Bollywood in Hobart’s CBD as Franklin Square hosts Diwali, the Indian festival of light

The Indian TelegraphOctober 20, 2017
Dhanteras 2017: Why do you buy gold, silver and utensils on this day; and things to remember while buying

Dhanteras 2017: Why do you buy gold, silver and utensils on this day; and things to remember while buying

The Indian TelegraphOctober 17, 2017
Official launch of Adani's Carmichael mine cancelled

Official launch of Adani’s Carmichael mine cancelled

The Indian TelegraphOctober 16, 2017
Diwali festival to light up Blacktown Showground this Sunday

Diwali festival to light up Blacktown Showground this Sunday

The Indian TelegraphOctober 14, 2017

Inside the mind of Ruma Mundi

The Indian TelegraphOctober 12, 2017