Proposed citizenship changes might have prevented Sydney siege, official says

Proposed citizenship changes might have prevented Sydney siege, official says

Immigration department assistant secretary tells senators Man Haron Monis could have been deported under stricter laws

Sydney’s Lindt cafe siege might not have occurred if the Turnbull government’s proposed citizenship laws were already in place, an official from the immigration department has claimed.

David Wilden, the first assistant secretary of the department’s immigration and citizenship policy division, has told a parliamentary inquiry that the terrorist Man Haron Monis, who took 18 people hostage in December 2014, might have been deported years ago if immigration laws were stricter.

He said the Turnbull government’s proposed citizenship laws were designed to help authorities deal with Australia’s terrorist threat, and there was nothing wrong with asking people to show greater allegiance to Australia, as the laws require.

“If we had these citizenship laws in place, the Lindt cafe siege may not have occurred,” Wilden said on Thursday. “I know that’s contentious … [but] if these laws were in place, the gentleman in question would not have made it, all things being equal … into the citizenship status, at which point, when other offences that he had undertaken [were noted], he would have been subject to a 501 cancellation and could have been, you know, deported.”

The Greens senator Nick McKim said that was a “highly contentious” thing to say, but Wilden did not back down.

He said the government’s bill also put a high price on citizenship, and it was right for the government to want to stringently test someone’s integration in the community.

“The concept that we wouldn’t want to test someone’s integration in today’s environment where, whether we like it or not, terrorism is a much greater threat than it was in 2007 and, you know, the 1990s when previous changes [were made], is a little naive,” he said. “The government’s proposition is that citizenship strengthening could be … one of the factors that would help us deal with some of those threats.”

The inquiry also heard ethnic communities across Australia were gripped by an unprecedented level of fear as parliament considers its crackdown on citizenship laws.

Community members worry that the federal government’s proposed changes will negate their years of contribution to Australia and place in jeopardy the opportunities provided to new migrants.

Emma Campbell from the Federation of Ethnic Communities’ Councils of Australia told the committee the citizenship debate had ignited a grassroots response unlike any other.

“The level of fear and distress in culturally and linguistically diverse communities in Australia is extraordinary and unprecedented,” she said. “FECCA believes this bill will create a permanent underclass of Australian residents who will be denied the rights and opportunities of being welcomed and included as Australian citizens.”

The organisation suspects the proposed crackdown is driven by politics rather than any empirical evidence.

Sam Wong, representing the Chinese community, flagged particular concerns with toughening English language requirements for aspiring citizens, labelling the move “amazingly strange” and difficult to accept.
Wong expected the crackdown would dissuade migrants from non-English-speaking countries from coming to Australia.

He said there was no evidence to suggest those proficient in English made stronger contributions.

Lawyers have also expressed serious concerns about the English tests, not least because the introduction of a “competent” requirement is not defined by legislation.

Online Source: The Guardian


More in Community

Top of the Class

Rekha RajvanshiFebruary 20, 2018

New Laws Protect Students From Sexual Predators

The Indian TelegraphFebruary 20, 2018

From Baahubali to Butter Chicken: Prabhas Unplugged

Aarti Kapur SinghFebruary 20, 2018

Pink Or Blue?

ManasiFebruary 20, 2018

The Curious Case Of Anant Ambani

Twinkle GhoshFebruary 20, 2018

Time for a “SAVE ADANI” yet?

Vish ViswanathanFebruary 7, 2018

Bollywood Gupshup

Aarti Kapur SinghFebruary 6, 2018

Australia, Its Refugees & The Moral Depravity Lurking Within

Pankaj YadavFebruary 6, 2018

A Dream Worth $50,000

Shivani SinghalFebruary 6, 2018

Tadasana: Be As Sturdy As A Mountain

Susheela SrinivasFebruary 6, 2018

Endgame Adani Or Far From It?

Shivani SinghalFebruary 6, 2018

NSW Encouraged To Celebrate Safely This Australia Day

The Indian TelegraphJanuary 25, 2018

In The Name Of Guns, Cannabis & The Holy Yoga

Twinkle GhoshJanuary 25, 2018

The Gopi Factory & The Badminton Revolution That Is Here To Stay

Boria MajumdarJanuary 23, 2018

Were the No voters mistreated?

Pankaj YadavJanuary 23, 2018

Pride, Prejudice & Padma

Twinkle GhoshJanuary 23, 2018

THE KAPOOR WITH A DIFFERENCE: The Man, His Movies, His magic

Twinkle GhoshJanuary 23, 2018

Busting Myths About Australia: Yours Truly, The Flat Earth Society

Shivani SinghalJanuary 23, 2018

Tasmania: Australia’s ‘Land down under’

Vishnu NairJanuary 23, 2018

‘Potentially Hazardous’ Asteroid The Size Of The Burj Khalifa Is Heading Towards The Earth At 67,000mph

The Indian TelegraphJanuary 18, 2018

Stay Indoors! Sydney Set To Bake In 43 Degree Temperatures Again During Five-Day Heatwave

The Indian TelegraphJanuary 18, 2018