Community

Computer says no: Irish vet fails oral English test needed to stay in Australia

Computer says no: Irish vet fails oral English test needed to stay in Australia

Louise Kennedy, a native English speaker with two degrees, says flawed technology is to blame

An Irish veterinarian with degrees in history and politics has been unable to convince a machine she can speak English well enough to stay in Australia.

Louise Kennedy is a native English speaker, has excellent grammar and a broad vocabulary. She holds two university degrees – both obtained in English – and has been working in Australia as an equine vet on a skilled worker visa for the past two years.

But she is now scrambling for other visa options after a computer-based English test – scored by a machine – essentially handed her a fail in terms of convincing immigration officers she can fluently speak her own language.

Earlier this year, Kennedy decided she would seek permanent residency in Australia on the grounds of her vocation, as a shortage profession. She knew she would have to sit a mandatory English proficiency test but was shocked when she got the results of her Pearson Test of English (PTE) Academic.

While she blitzed all other components of the test including writing and reading, she failed to reach the minimum score immigration requires in oral fluency. She got 74 when the government requires 79.

Kennedy went to Pearson, which administers the PTE test. Pearson is one of five test providers the immigration department uses to assess English competency for visa purposes.

But it is the only one that uses voice recognition technology to test speaking ability, with audio recordings then marked by a “scoring engine” that has been trained to identify acceptable and unacceptable answers to questions that pop up on a computer screen.

Other test providers have said they use human assessors to determine if people are competent speakers of English. Kennedy is convinced the PTE technology is flawed.

“There’s obviously a flaw in their computer software, when a person with perfect oral fluency cannot get enough points,” she said.

Pearson has categorically denied there is anything wrong with its computer-based test or the scoring engine trained to analyse candidates’ responses.

Sasha Hampson, the head of English for Pearson Asia Pacific, says the immigration department set the bar very high for people seeking permanent residency.

Pearson, which conducts its PTE test worldwide for a wide range of purposes, does not offer a pass or a fail, simply a score.

Kennedy, who is due to have a baby in October, says she will now have to pursue a bridging visa, while she seeks a more expensive spouse visa so she can remain with her Australian husband.

Online Source: The Guardian

Community

More in Community

National disability insurance scheme 'faceless' and rigid, inquiry told

National disability insurance scheme ‘faceless’ and rigid, inquiry told

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 20, 2017
Lord Ganesha

Calls to ban ‘insulting’ lamb ad featuring Ganesha dismissed by standards bureau

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 19, 2017
Shark alert issued after man injured in Point Samson

Shark alert issued after man injured in Point Samson

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 12, 2017
Peppa Pig 'spiders can't hurt you' episode pulled off air in Australia – again

Peppa Pig ‘spiders can’t hurt you’ episode pulled off air in Australia – again

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 5, 2017
Australian Number Plate Sells For Record-Breaking $2.45 Million

Australian Number Plate Sells For Record-Breaking $2.45 Million

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 2, 2017
Shark nets to be trialled again on New South Wales north coast beaches

Shark nets to be trialled again on New South Wales north coast beaches

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 1, 2017
Police search for man who indecently assaulted teenager

Police search for man who indecently assaulted teenager

The Indian TelegraphAugust 30, 2017
Australia offers to train Philippine army in fight against Islamic State

Australia offers to train Philippine army in fight against Islamic State

The Indian TelegraphAugust 29, 2017
Bail for man accused of driving getaway car in Bondi attack

Bail for man accused of driving getaway car in Bondi attack

The Indian TelegraphAugust 26, 2017
National Skills Week 2017: Vocational training is the first step for many creative careers

National Skills Week 2017: Vocational training is the first step for many creative careers

The Indian TelegraphAugust 26, 2017
Proposed citizenship changes might have prevented Sydney siege, official says

Proposed citizenship changes might have prevented Sydney siege, official says

The Indian TelegraphAugust 25, 2017
Coalition urges high court to fast-track MPs' citizenship cases

Coalition urges high court to fast-track MPs’ citizenship cases

The Indian TelegraphAugust 23, 2017
Facebook

Senate hears Facebook pays news publishers average of $100 a day to use content

The Indian TelegraphAugust 23, 2017
Drivers are being urged to stay clear of central Moonee Ponds as police conduct safety checks

Drivers are being urged to stay clear of central Moonee Ponds as police conduct safety checks

The Indian TelegraphAugust 21, 2017
New door-to-station shuttle service to be trialled for commuters

New door-to-station shuttle service to be trialled for commuters

The Indian TelegraphAugust 18, 2017

Happy Independence Day

The Indian TelegraphAugust 15, 2017
Student sentenced over racist attack on Muslim woman caught on film

Student sentenced over racist attack on Muslim woman caught on film

The Indian TelegraphAugust 14, 2017
Port Augusta solar thermal plant to power South Australian government

Port Augusta solar thermal plant to power South Australian government

The Indian TelegraphAugust 14, 2017
Sydney woman prosecuted for taking abortion drug

Sydney woman prosecuted for taking abortion drug

The Indian TelegraphAugust 14, 2017
Karen Ristevski’s stepson Anthony Rickard starts Facebook murder blog

Karen Ristevski’s stepson Anthony Rickard starts Facebook murder blog

The Indian TelegraphAugust 12, 2017
Australia’s most wanted fugitive Graham Gene Potter has been spotted in NSW

Australia’s most wanted fugitive Graham Gene Potter has been spotted in NSW

The Indian TelegraphAugust 11, 2017