Community

Big victory for Baird mergers as Woollahra Council loses court challenge

Big victory for Baird mergers as Woollahra Council loses court challenge

A Sydney council has decisively lost its legal challenge against the state government’s plans to merge it forcibly with other councils, in a dispiriting sign for a string of other councils that have mounted challenges against the plans.

It took only minutes for Chief Judge Brian Preston of the Land and Environment Court to dismiss Woollahra Council’s challenge to Baird government plans to merge it forcibly with Randwick and Waverley councils.

Costs were awarded against the council, in what is likely to be interpreted as a major victory for the government.

Judge Preston dismissed many of the fundamental points the council raised against the policy, which would decrease the number of councils in NSW by about 40.

The news will be a blow to a string of other Sydney councils that have voted to commence legal action, including North Sydney, Ku-ring-gai, Mosman, Strathfield and Hunters Hill councils.

Those councils’ cases rest on many of the same principles advanced by Woollahra, but their cases are challenging different aspects of the manner in which the government made and executed the case for mergers.

Speaking briefly to reporters outside the court, the mayor of Woollahra, Toni Zeltzer, said she was “significantly disappointed” by the ruling.

The council has only a few days to appeal against the verdict. That window closes on Monday. It is not yet clear if the council will appeal but it has said it is considering its options.

If it does not, that means the state government could begin the process of merging the councils as early as next week. The government is understood to be waiting for Woollahra’s response to the verdict.

Other Sydney councils merged in May. But those mounting legal challenges are exempt until their avenues for appealing the government’s move are exhausted.

Local Government Minister Paul Toole said the legal win for the government showed that the government had followed the correct processes when merging NSW councils.

Woollahra had allocated most of its $180,000 annual litigation budget to fighting the case. Paying the government’s costs is likely to blow out that budget considerably.

Other councils mounting challenges, such as Ku-ring-gai, have already shelled out more than $120,000 in costs.

Councillors had argued the money was a defensible use of income from ratepayers because, they argued, rates would rise if the council was merged.

Greens MLC David Shoebridge acknowledged the decision was a setback.

But he denied it was the end of the road for Woollahra and the string of other councils fighting the government’s plans to amalgamate them with other councils.

“This is only the first stage in the legal challenge with an inevitable appeal being filed in the Supreme Court in coming days,” he said.

“Not only will we see an appeal in this case, but there are a series of separate cases, with separate legal points and unique factual circumstances from other councils that are also before the Courts.”

Online Source

The Indian Telegraph Sydney Australia

Community

More in Community

Aussies ‘treated like criminals’ at US border

Aussies ‘treated like criminals’ at US border

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 25, 2017
National disability insurance scheme 'faceless' and rigid, inquiry told

National disability insurance scheme ‘faceless’ and rigid, inquiry told

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 20, 2017
Lord Ganesha

Calls to ban ‘insulting’ lamb ad featuring Ganesha dismissed by standards bureau

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 19, 2017
Shark alert issued after man injured in Point Samson

Shark alert issued after man injured in Point Samson

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 12, 2017
Peppa Pig 'spiders can't hurt you' episode pulled off air in Australia – again

Peppa Pig ‘spiders can’t hurt you’ episode pulled off air in Australia – again

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 5, 2017
Australian Number Plate Sells For Record-Breaking $2.45 Million

Australian Number Plate Sells For Record-Breaking $2.45 Million

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 2, 2017
Shark nets to be trialled again on New South Wales north coast beaches

Shark nets to be trialled again on New South Wales north coast beaches

The Indian TelegraphSeptember 1, 2017
Police search for man who indecently assaulted teenager

Police search for man who indecently assaulted teenager

The Indian TelegraphAugust 30, 2017
Australia offers to train Philippine army in fight against Islamic State

Australia offers to train Philippine army in fight against Islamic State

The Indian TelegraphAugust 29, 2017
Bail for man accused of driving getaway car in Bondi attack

Bail for man accused of driving getaway car in Bondi attack

The Indian TelegraphAugust 26, 2017
National Skills Week 2017: Vocational training is the first step for many creative careers

National Skills Week 2017: Vocational training is the first step for many creative careers

The Indian TelegraphAugust 26, 2017
Proposed citizenship changes might have prevented Sydney siege, official says

Proposed citizenship changes might have prevented Sydney siege, official says

The Indian TelegraphAugust 25, 2017
Coalition urges high court to fast-track MPs' citizenship cases

Coalition urges high court to fast-track MPs’ citizenship cases

The Indian TelegraphAugust 23, 2017
Facebook

Senate hears Facebook pays news publishers average of $100 a day to use content

The Indian TelegraphAugust 23, 2017
Drivers are being urged to stay clear of central Moonee Ponds as police conduct safety checks

Drivers are being urged to stay clear of central Moonee Ponds as police conduct safety checks

The Indian TelegraphAugust 21, 2017
New door-to-station shuttle service to be trialled for commuters

New door-to-station shuttle service to be trialled for commuters

The Indian TelegraphAugust 18, 2017

Happy Independence Day

The Indian TelegraphAugust 15, 2017
Student sentenced over racist attack on Muslim woman caught on film

Student sentenced over racist attack on Muslim woman caught on film

The Indian TelegraphAugust 14, 2017
Port Augusta solar thermal plant to power South Australian government

Port Augusta solar thermal plant to power South Australian government

The Indian TelegraphAugust 14, 2017
Sydney woman prosecuted for taking abortion drug

Sydney woman prosecuted for taking abortion drug

The Indian TelegraphAugust 14, 2017
Karen Ristevski’s stepson Anthony Rickard starts Facebook murder blog

Karen Ristevski’s stepson Anthony Rickard starts Facebook murder blog

The Indian TelegraphAugust 12, 2017